Insurance and Surrender in Blackjack Explained: Is Either Option a Good Idea?

Eddie Griffin

Written by: Eddie Griffin

Last Updated:

Read Time: 10 minutes

In the complex world of blackjack strategy, two often misunderstood options available to players are insurance and surrender. While both serve as protective measures against potential losses, they function differently and should be used in specific situations.

This deep dive into insurance and surrender will explore both options in detail, helping you make informed decisions at the blackjack table. So, when you step up to a real table at a physical casino or the table at top online casinos such as OnlineCasinoGames, Wild Casino, and Super Slots Casino, you will know how to approach scenarios in which insurance and surrender may come into play.

Build Your Knowledge—And Your Bankroll—With Our Comprehensive Casino Guides

Along with our sports betting guides, we provide a collection of casino content covering the basics of casino gambling. That includes this guide to insurance and surrender in blackjack.

If you would like to learn more about everything from online casino terminology, to how to play popular table games such as baccarat, to tips for responsible gambling, we have you covered. Our selection of casino guides continues to grow, and our goal is to be a vital resource for players who enjoy playing blackjack, video poker, and other popular online casino games.

Also, if you are looking for a new site to play casino games, check out our reviews of the best online casinos for U.S. players and the best real money online casinos., as well as our rundown of the best crypto casinos.

Understanding Insurance in Blackjack

In blackjack, insurance is a side bet that becomes available when the dealer’s upcard is an ace. This bet, which costs half your original wager, essentially protects you against the dealer having a natural blackjack (a two-card 21).

If the dealer does have blackjack, the insurance bet pays 2:1, effectively allowing you to break even on the hand despite losing your original wager.

The mechanics of insurance are straightforward. When the dealer shows an ace, they will offer insurance before checking their hole card. From there, there are a few possible outcomes:

  • If you accept insurance, you place half your original bet as the insurance wager.
  • If the dealer has a ten-value card (10, Jack, Queen, or King) as their hole card, you win the insurance bet but lose your original wager (unless you also have blackjack).
  • And if the dealer doesn’t have blackjack, you lose the insurance bet, and the hand continues normally.

Do note that while insurance is available in American blackjack games, it is not available in European blackjack games.

Understanding Surrender in Blackjack

Surrender in blackjack is a different defensive option that allows you to forfeit your hand and recover half your original bet rather than playing it out.

This option typically becomes available after the dealer checks for blackjack (if they’re showing an ace or ten) and before you take any other action on your hand. When you surrender, you immediately give up your hand and receive half your bet back, rather than risking losing the entire amount.

There are two types of surrender: early surrender and late surrender. Early surrender allows you to surrender before the dealer checks for blackjack. Late surrender only becomes available after the dealer checks for blackjack.

At modern casinos, early surrender rarely features. Late surrender is the more common option when surrender is offered at all.

Also, while insurance is not an option in European blackjack, surrender is sometimes available in European blackjack games.

The Mathematics Behind Insurance

From a mathematical perspective, taking insurance in blackjack profiles as an infrequently profitable bet. The insurance bet only wins when the dealer has a ten-value card in the hole, which represents 4 out of 13 possible card values.

This means the true odds of the dealer having blackjack are 9:4 against, but the insurance bet only pays 2:1. This creates a significant house edge on the insurance bet of approximately 7.4% in a single-deck game, with the edge increasing in games with multiple decks.

The only situation where blackjack insurance becomes mathematically profitable is when you’re counting cards and know that the deck is rich in ten-value cards. For basic strategy players who aren’t counting cards, taking insurance is almost always a losing proposition in the long run, regardless of your hand or the current situation.

Strategic Considerations for Surrender

Surrender, while not always available in blackjack games at traditional casinos or real money online casinos such as Uptown Aces Casino and Red Stag Casino, can be a valuable option in specific situations.

The decision to surrender should be based on the total of your hand and the dealer’s upcard. Late surrender is typically correct when you have a hard 16 (including pairs of 8s) against a dealer’s 9, 10, or ace, and with a hard 15 against a dealer’s 10.

The mathematical basis for surrender decisions in blackjack is straightforward. You should surrender when your probability of winning the hand is less than 25% and your probability of losing is greater than 75%.

Why is this? Surrendering guarantees you will lose 50% of your bet. Therefore, you only want to surrender when playing the hand would result in losing more than 50% of the time.

Comparing Insurance and Surrender

While both insurance and surrender are defensive options in blackjack, they serve fundamentally different purposes and come into play in distinct situations. Understanding these differences is crucial for optimal decision-making at the blackjack table.

Insurance is a side bet that only protects against dealer blackjack. It functions as a form of hedge against a specific dealer outcome. It requires an additional wager and is only available when the dealer shows an ace.

The decision to take insurance should be independent of your hand strength. Even if you have a strong hand like a 20, insurance remains a mathematically losing proposition for basic strategy players.

Surrender, conversely, is a way to cut your losses on particularly weak hands when faced with a strong dealer upcard. Unlike insurance, surrender doesn’t require an additional bet. Instead, it allows you to forfeit half your original wager and end the hand immediately. This option is particularly valuable because it allows you to minimize losses in situations where you’re heavily unfavored to win.

The timing of these decisions also differs significantly.

Insurance must be decided immediately after the initial deal when the dealer shows an ace, before any other actions are taken. Surrender, when available, comes after the dealer checks for blackjack but before you take any other action on your hand.

This timing difference means that with surrender, you have more information about your chances of winning before making the decision.

Is Insurance or Surrender Better?

  • Insurance is almost never the correct play unless you’re counting cards, even with strong hands and sizable bets. The house edge on insurance is substantial (7.4% or higher), making it a terrible bet for basic strategy players.
  • Surrender, when available, can be the mathematically correct play in specific situations, particularly with hard 15 or 16 against strong dealer upcards. The mathematical threshold for surrender (losing more than 75% of the time) provides clear guidance for when to use this option.

From a risk management perspective, these options operate differently.

Insurance attempts to protect your entire original bet but requires risking additional money. Surrender guarantees a loss of exactly half your bet but protects you from losing the full amount. This makes surrender a more straightforward and often more useful tool for navigating unfavorable situations.

Also, the frequency of optimal use differs dramatically between these options.

Basic blackjack strategy charts never recommend taking insurance without card counting. On the other side, surrender receives recommendations in several specific hand/dealer combinations. This makes surrender a more practical tool for the average player, provided it’s available at their casino.

Additionally, impact on overall blackjack game strategy varies.

Insurance decisions are relatively simple – basic strategy players should decline it every time. Surrender decisions, however, require careful consideration of both your hand and the dealer’s upcard, making them a more nuanced part of optimal play.

Furthermore, the availability of surrender can influence other strategic decisions, such as splitting pairs or whether to hit or stand on certain totals.

When evaluating these options, surrender clearly emerges as the more valuable tool long-term for basic strategy players. While both options are designed to minimize losses, surrender does so more effectively and with a clearer mathematical basis. Insurance, by contrast, tends to accelerate losses for players who are not counting cards.

House Edge Considerations

The house edge impact of these options varies significantly.

Insurance carries a substantial house edge of 7.4% or higher, making it one of the worst bets in the casino for non-card counters. Surrender, on the other hand, when used correctly, can actually reduce the overall blackjack house edge by about 0.08%.

Making the Right Decision

With insurance and surrender and any other strategic concepts in blackjack, your decision-making process should be based on basic strategy and the specific rules of the game you’re playing.

For non-card counters, the general rule is simple. Never take insurance and only surrender in the specific situations outlined by basic strategy charts. Remember that both options are designed to minimize losses rather than maximize wins, so they should be used sparingly and only in appropriate situations.

When evaluating surrender situations, key hand combinations to remember include hard 16 against dealer 9 through ace, and hard 15 against a dealer’s 10. Some basic strategy variations also recommend surrendering hard 17 against dealer ace in certain multi-deck games where surrender is available.

The composition of your hard hands can sometimes matter. For example, a hard 16 composed of three or more cards might be played differently than a two-card 16.

The decision process becomes more nuanced when considering table rules and variations.

For example, your considerations may be different with playing a game of single deck blackjack than with a game of multi-hand blackjack, which features several decks.

Or in games where dealers hit on soft 17, surrender becomes more valuable because the dealer’s drawing potential increases.

Similarly, the number of decks in play can slightly affect optimal surrender strategy. However, these adjustments are usually too minor for basic strategy players to consider.

Verify the surrender rules before sitting down to play. If surrender isn’t available, you’ll need to adjust your strategy accordingly – usually hitting in situations where you would otherwise surrender. Never let the absence of surrender affect your insurance decisions; these should remain completely separate strategic considerations.

Common decision-making errors to avoid include taking insurance as “protection” for large bets, surrendering after taking other actions on your hand, or failing to surrender eligible hands because you “feel lucky.” Stick to the mathematically correct plays regardless of recent results or bet size.

Conclusion

Understanding when to use insurance and surrender in blackjack is crucial for developing a solid strategic approach to the game. While insurance is rarely the correct play for basic strategy players, proper use of surrender can help minimize losses in particularly unfavorable situations.

Remember that both options should be viewed as defensive tools rather than ways to gain an advantage over the house.

As with all aspects of blackjack strategy, the key is to make mathematically correct decisions based on the specific situation rather than emotion or intuition.

As with other concepts and strategies in blackjack and other casino games, we recommend familiarizing yourself with them.

Many of the best blackjack sites, such as DuckyLuck Casino and Lucky Red Casino, allow players to play demo versions of their games so that they can get the hang of them before risking real money. Take full advantage of these options to increase your knowledge of rules, strategies, and the mechanics of online casino games.

Learn About the Best Online Casinos

Insurance vs Surrender FAQ

When should I take insurance in blackjack?
As a basic strategy player, you should never take insurance. The only exception is if you’re counting cards and know the deck is rich in ten-value cards, making the insurance bet mathematically profitable.
Is surrender available in blackjack at all casinos?
No, surrender is not universally offered. Late surrender is more common than early surrender, but many casinos don’t offer either option. Always check the specific rules of the table before playing.
Can I surrender after hitting in blackjack?
No, surrender must be your first and only action on a hand. Once you’ve hit, split, or doubled down, the surrender option is no longer available.
What is the difference between early surrender and late surrender in blackjack?
Early surrender allows you to surrender before the dealer checks for blackjack, while late surrender only becomes available after the dealer checks. Early surrender is extremely rare in modern casinos.
Should I take insurance even with a blackjack?
Even with a blackjack, insurance is generally not recommended unless you’re counting cards. The mathematics of the insurance bet remain unfavorable regardless of your hand.
Is surrender better than insurance in blackjack?
When used correctly according to basic strategy, surrender is mathematically superior to insurance for non-card counters. Surrender can reduce the house edge when used properly, while insurance increases it.